Three thinkers 

Sigmund Freud 
Alfred Adler 
Carl Jung

I dreamed I stood before a door.
It would not move all night.
Three thinkers crossed the creaking floor.
Could all of them be right?
 
Freud might look back into my past.
What happened long before?
What taught my heart to beat so fast
when someone slammed a door?
 
Then Adler asks what fear might do.
What could it keep at bay?
If I’m too scared to walk on through,
what choice can wait a day?
 
Now Jung might ask who waits inside,
whom I don’t want to see.
What if the one I try to hide
is one more side of me?
 
What’s real? What’s fair? Who gets to say?
What makes a reason sound?
How much of what I think today
did I pick up around town?
 
If every lock must take a key,
then this one takes one too.
The next step’s plain enough to see.
But is the first claim true?
 
Three doors swung open at a touch.
I thought the fourth one might.
It stuck. I’d learned at least this much:
a hunch is not quite sight.
 
A man sells keys to every door.
A crowd lines up to buy.
His key gets stuck. He tries once more,
then calls the lock a lie.
 
My favorite thinker has a key.
I like to watch it shine.
Would his mistakes stand out to me
if his beliefs weren’t mine?
 
Before I build my life on this,
what would I need to see?
And what new rooms might I still miss
if I keep just one key?


Each thinker took a different view
of what a life could mean.
What did each have to take as true,
and what went by unseen?
 
A promise shines beneath the lights;
I want it to be true.
He says he’ll stand for all our rights,
but does “all” mean just a few?
 
Who taught me which face to admire,
whose pain I need not see?
If I’d been raised beside your fire,
what would seem right to me?
 
Old bones can show what came before,
how life has changed its face.
If I ask what that change was for,
would purpose leave a trace?
 
What if a thought I’ve called my own
can’t stand the light of day?
What could I build if that one stone
no longer had to stay?

…

DCG

Sigmund Freud is one of the main reasons why society is extremely weak. And before you attack me, hear me out. There are three founding fathers in psychology: Sigmund Freud, Alfred Adler, and Carl Jung. Now, they all started together. Same time, same place, same goal. But then they split. Why?
Because Freud believed in etiology, which is the study of causes. And it sounds like this: You are anxious because your brother bullied you. You are not in a relationship because your parents abandoned you. You stutter because your father was harsh with you. In other words, you are only the consequence of what happened to you. This is extremely deterministic, and it’s extremely limiting. I hope you can see that. The problem is, his ideas spread in the world like a virus.


Alfred Adler wasn’t having it. He believed in [teleology], which is the study of purpose. And it sounds like this: You are not anxious because of your childhood. You subconsciously manufacture anxiety as a means to justify the present. As a means to justify why you are underperforming. As a means to justify why you are not in a relationship. As a means to justify why you are afraid of going out. In other words, you are not shaped by what happened to you, but you are shaped by what you are trying to avoid.
And the problem is, his ideas never spread, because we human beings, we love being victims.

—The ideas themselves almost certainly come from “The Courage to Be Disliked” by Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga (2013), a popular book on Adler.

• Freud is oversimplified. He did put early experience first, but his aim was helping patients understand themselves so they could change, not to fix them as victims of the past.


• The history is off. Adler and Jung were not equal co-founders working “same time, same place, same goal.” Both started out in Freud’s circle: Adler broke away around 1911 and Jung around 1913.


Completing the Jung progression


Following the clip’s pattern, the speaker would cast Jung as the third option. Freud looks back at causes, Adler looks forward at purpose, and Jung looks inward and forward toward wholeness.

Carl Jung went further. He believed in individuation, the process of becoming who you truly are. And it sounds like this: You are anxious because there is a part of yourself you refuse to face. You keep attracting the same partner because you are projecting your own shadow onto them. Your crisis isn’t a breakdown; it’s your psyche demanding that you grow. In other words, you are not only what happened to you, and not only what you avoid. You are what you have not yet become.
“Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.”

The conclusion he’s heading toward: Freud explains you, Adler gives you responsibility, and Jung gives you meaning. Each man’s psychology carries a philosophy:
• Freud is deterministic: the past is in charge.
• Adler stresses free will and courage: you choose your goals, and your symptoms serve those goals.
• Jung is close to spiritual: the psyche aims at wholeness. You grow by bringing together your conscious self and your unconscious (the shadow, archetypes, the Self). Suffering means something and can lead to transformation.
So the reel’s punchline would likely be: stop asking “what happened to me” (Freud), start asking “what am I avoiding” (Adler), and ultimately ask “who am I meant to become” (Jung). That’s the line from victimhood to responsibility to self-realization.